
BNBF Scottish 2006
Edinburgh’s University Theatre was once again the venue for the opening qualifier of the BNBF season. This year, the Scottish attracted 38 competitors, and, as has come to be expected, the standard was high, with some very tight judging decisions made. On this occasion, the judging panel comprised WNBF Pro’s Vicky McCann, David Hannah, Chris Nsbuga, Cheryl Myers and double WNBF World Champion Rob Hope, with Scottish bodybuilding and powerlifting champion Mike Duffy assuming the role of head judge for the first time. WNBF Pro Rachael Hayes did a fine job as compere for the evening.
JUNIORS – sponsored by Gracemount Gym
Five juniors opened the show, receiving a great reception
from the capacity crowd. All the lads were well up for this, and battled
to the very end, and the judges’ decision was accepted sportingly.
1st: Andrew Chappell – Andrew was confident
(without being OTT) from the outset. Smiling throughout, he had the most
complete and balanced development in the class, and his condition was bang-on,
with deep cuts and striations, particularly in the upper body. With posing,
he became extremely vascular across his thickly-developed pecs and shoulders.
With a competent routine, Andrew was the obvious winner from the moment
he took the stage.
2nd: David Harper – David was tall and
lean, with a deeply chiselled midsection and a strong upper body, which
matched Andrew’s for condition. His quads were well separated, but
his legs, particularly hamstrings, needed a little more size to bring up
his symmetry. Otherwise, a very strong performance from David.
3rd: Jonathan Mortimer – Jonathan had
a lovely shape, with wide lats and shoulders and narrow hips, which gave
him a natural taper. His condition was fair, although not enough to challenge
the top two, and like David, he needs to bring up his legs to balance his
symmetry. Although not the biggest in the line-up, he had very good stage
presence, which drew the eye.
4th: Robbie Bell – Robbie was huge, with
good depth to his upper body in particular. Unfortunately, his condition
was well off today, particularly in his legs, which detracted from his physique.
If Robbie can work hard on that, he will place top three for certain in
the not-too-distant future.
5th: - Leigh McNiven – Leigh was tall
with a fair level of development, particularly his pecs. Leigh just needs
a bit more of everything (size, condition) to be more competitive in future.
MASTERS - sponsored by Pronutrition
Seven Masters lined up to contest this prize, two of whom were classed as Over 60’s. Again, it was a very strong line-up, a perfect demonstration that bodybuilding can be a lifelong sport.
1st: David Reid – Davy
presented a much improved physique today. He has always had tremendous condition,
but today looked to have added depth and thickness to his frame without
losing any of the said condition. His shoulders were wide and full, pecs
shredded, his biceps well peaked and the detail in his back was outstanding.
To be picky, although Davy’s legs have come on a lot, he could still
add a little more size, particularly hamstring development, to balance his
physique further, but a great return to competition after taking a year
out.
2nd: John Chalmers – John must have worked
hard to bring about the improvements he showed today. Ripped to the bone
from head to toe, he also looked much fuller than on previous occasions,
which benefited his shape and symmetry. His condition was as good as anyone’s
on the stage today, with his hamstrings particularly remarkable. John could
still afford to fill out his delts and triceps a little more, but he thoroughly
deserved his placing today, and was delighted.
3rd: Charlie McKee – Charlie looked impressive
from the outset. The most thickly-muscled of all, his shoulders, arms and
pecs were extremely rounded and dense, and his tan was bang-on. However,
Charlie, in his lat poses, tends to round his shoulders and back forwards,
to the extent that he looks narrow, and his legs were not a match for his
upper body, which threw out his symmetry. Charlie has a good stage persona,
and if he can work on these details will place higher.
4th: Samuel Meikle – Sam has a very good
basic shape, with strong quads, pecs, traps and biceps, however his condition
let him down today, although he was tighter at the night show than during
the afternoon judging, and he came through the more he posed.
5th: Jim Richardson – Jim had a reasonable level of development, and
showed agility and originality in his routine, but he too needs to work
hard on his condition to place higher in future.
MASTERS OVER-60
This class saw a good-natured re-match of the battle between
last year’s winner and current British champion Eric Dowey and Ted
Clifton, who possibly competes more than anyone else in the country. Incredibly,
both men continue to make gains with each successive year. Both men continue
to show an enthusiasm for their sport that belies their years.
1st: Eric Dowey – Eric, who turns 70
later this year, has an enviable shape; wide shoulders and lats, with a
narrow waist, give him a V-shape the envy of many a younger man, and his
legs remain full and cut. His journey from Bangor was rewarded with the
title.
2nd: Ted Clifton – Ted was as good as
I’ve seen him today, having achieved a good balance between size and
condition. His routine was, as ever, lively and rousing. Well done Ted.
NOVICE – sponsored by Bodytek Gym
As ever, the largest class of the day, with 10 entrants.
The usual contrast of heights, shapes and sizes ensured that the judges
were kept on their toes.
1st: Tissot Regis – from the outset,
Tissot looked like the winner. He presented the most complete, balanced
physique in the line-up, with wide, full shoulders and lats tapering to
a tiny midsection, and flared thighs. His back was phenomenally thick, and
his skintone was perfect. If Tissot can come in around 7lb lighter for the
final, he should place very highly indeed.
2nd: Jim Blyth – Jim has a big frame
with plenty of dense muscle, and a good shape, although at times, he looked
ever-so-slightly narrow across the front delts. He was in good condition,
with striated pecs and very good detail in his back (very prominent “Christmas
tree” in his lower back), and by the night show, he had tightened
further to the extent that his glutes were striated, although his quads
were just a tad lacking in detail by comparison.
3rd: Mikey Craig – Mikey demonstrated
very strong proportions, with a good over-all level of development and condition,
with cuts and separations evident. His presentation and conduct on stage
throughout the day were exemplary, and earned him the “Best Presentation
“ award for male competitors today. Mikey could still add a little
more depth to his pecs and tighten the hamstrings, but otherwise, a very
good debut performance.
4th: Allan Barbour – Tall and lean, Allan
had the best condition in the class (without becoming “stringy”),
particularly across the shoulders and arms. To improve his proportions,
he just needs to add a little more leg size. Allan really fought on stage,
and looked like he was enjoying himself.
Also competing today: Steven Black (reasonable
size, needs to improve condition); Richard Connelly
(good shape and thickness, again needs to work on condition); Paul
Gardner (strong pecs, delts and legs, needs more lat width to improve
taper); Bernard Hume (very wide with a good
taper and density and big legs, needs to work on pecs, hamstrings, condition
and tan. Good potential); Narash Kumar (deceptively
slight at first, came out with posing, with good shoulders and arms, needs
to bring up legs to match upper body); Felix McAlinden
(continues to improve with each contest, deep cuts to abs and quads, still
needs more over-all size). Well done to all the novices, many of whom were
first-time competitors today.
MISS PHYSIQUE – sponsored by Udo’s Choice Blended Oil
Two ladies in the line-up; could last year’s winner retain her title? Both ladies gave a strong performance on the day.
1st: Hazel Kidd – Hazel
took this class last year, and subsequently went on to an excellent third
place in the Britain. She has a very wide back, hence a natural V-taper,
and her legs are very good, particularly her quads, which are full and cut.
Her routines are always entertaining and well-thought-out, and her preparation
was bang-on. I’d still like to see Hazel add muscle to her arms, chest
and shoulders, and improve her condition further, which will nip in her
waist and give her even more taper, but she had done enough to win the class
and retain her title today.
2nd: Crow Dillon-Parkin – making her
bodybuilding debut, Crow was lean and tight in the upper body, with a tiny
waist, defined pecs and well-developed biceps. She had very commanding stage
presence, and performed an entertaining routine with some difficult moves.
Crow needs to work on tighteninig her legs, glutes and hips to the level
of her upper body, and adding size to her upper body will give her a more
balanced look, but nonetheless, a very promising debut.
Today saw the return of Chris Nsbuga
to the stage where he finally won his Pro card at his third attempt in the
autumn of 2005. Since then, Chris has thrown himself wholeheartedly into
the BNBF, and he did not let the expectant crowd down. His shape is without
parallel: huge, rounded delts and flared lats tapering to the smallest of
waists; muscular full thighs…
Chris began his guest spot with a graceful,
classic routine, showing off his lines and symmetry to full advantage. However
Chris has a personality even bigger than his frame, and it is when this
is allowed to shine through that he is at his best; when he came on for
the second part of his spot wearing the hugest of afro wigs, bright yellow
to match his posing trunks, the entire venue went into uproar, especially
when he jumped down off the stage and stormed into the crowd, hitting pose
after pose as he went. Anyone who somehow happened to be looking the wrong
way was tapped on the shoulder and reminded of why this guy won his Pro
card. The crowd at the Scottish is always noisy, but never has a guest star
captured their attention like Chris did today.
He is a great asset to the BNBF, and organised a “tightest T-shirt”
competition for members of the audience. There were several willing (and
some not-so-willing) participants, the winner being judged on audience response.
LIGHTWEIGHTS – sponsored by Pronaturalmuscle.com
Originally five in number, the lightweights suddenly had
one more contender for the prize when a competitor originally entered in
the middleweight class weighed in under the weight limit for lightweights.
This was to alter the outcome of the lightweight category.
1st: Mike Battersby – a powerfully-built
athlete, the most complete and densely-muscled of all, Mike dominated this
class from the outset. Every muscle group was well-defined and detailed,
his midsection in particular showing deep cuts. During the afternoon session,
he was just a tiny tad soft in the glutes, but by the time the night show
came around, he was rock-hard, tight and dry. Dropping down a weight class
certainly paid off today, and a delighted Mike received his first place
trophy jointly from current WNBF World Champ Rob Hope, and his own seven-year-old
son, Michael Battersby Junior, a bodybuilder in the making, with the craziest
ab vacuum I’ve ever seen.
2nd: Colin Richardson – Colin has a beautiful
natural shape, with the best shoulder to waist taper in the class. His upper
body was his best asset today, with full shoulders, good arms, those H-U-G-E
lats and a miniscule waist. He was very well prepared for this, tight, full
and dry, although I didn’t feel he was quite as tight for the night
show. Whilst his legs were well-developed and defined, he could add a little
more size to further improve his already superb proportions. I think Colin
was phased slightly by the discovery that Mike had come down from middleweight,
and indeed Mike did carry too much muscle to be beaten, but Colin needs
to fight, fight, fight if he’s faced with such a situation again.
3rd: Phillip Bell – another competitor
blessed with stunning shape and symmetry. In many ways, he was similar in
shape and structure to Colin, although he was a little less dense, particularly
across the pecs, and he would have benefited from a deeper tan. Come the
night show, he had tightened up considerably and pushed Colin further, though
not quite enough to pip him for second. He presented himself really well
during all three rounds, and was a contender for the Best Presentation award.
4th: Danny O’Sullivan – a stocky
lightweight, whose best features were his shoulders, striated triceps and
back detail and definition. He needs a little more back width, and like
many others on the day, needs to bring up his leg development to the same
level as that of his upper body, notably outer thigh sweep, but otherwise,
a strong performance.
Also contesting this class were: Christopher Flanagan
(big arms and legs, and deep pecs, but just too soft to be a real threat
today) and Craig Jefferson (very lean, tight
and dry, ripped to shreds with deep cuts and separations, but lost it on
size here today; good stage persona throughout the day).
MIDDLEWEIGHTS – sponsored by Betta Bodies Clothing
What this class lacked in numbers, it made up in the quality
of the three athletes on stage; this class is often the most keenly-contested
of all, and today was no exception.
1st: Kerry Napier – Kerry made his return
to amateur competition having made a reluctant decision to relinquish his
Pro card for personal reasons, and what a return it was. For muscular thickness
and development, he could not be beaten today, showed off to perfection
by his level of condition. Kerry’s pecs, delts and arms were full
and rounded, his legs full and delineated, especially from the side, where
even his iliotibial band was clearly defined. Kerry’s back is dense
and full, but he could benefit from more lat width, and whilst his posing,
especially during the compulsories, has improved, he can still look a little
“wooden” at times, but he had done enough to claim victory in
this class today.
2nd: John Rafferty – last year’s
Scottish champion has a wonderful shape, a true X – frame, and every
year, he has made subtle gains. His shoulders are wide and full, adding
to the effect of his small waist and flared thighs, which were separated
and detailed from hip to knee in the quads. His abs were, as we have come
to expect from Jon, deeply carved. John still lacks a little fullness in
his pecs and depth to the triceps, and during the night show, his back detail
didn’t come through as it had during the afternoon, but John always
presents himself immaculately on stage and, just not as dense as Kerry,
took a well-deserved second.
3rd: Rob Carey – Rob has never appeared
in anything less than A-1 condition, and so it was today. He is tall for
a middleweight, and every bodypart is cross-cut with striations. He had
gained some size during his time away from competition, especially in the
legs, and his traps and pecs were particularly noteworthy. Unfortunately,
despite the said gains, in comparison with the two athletes who placed above
him today, Rod simply didn’t carry the density to place higher, but
he is nonetheless a great competitor with a quality physique, and received
an invite to the Britain.
MISS FIGURE – sponsored by bigredshark.com
Since its introduction into the BNBF repertoire, this class
has proved popular. Originally four in number, one girl withdrew her entry
at a late stage, leaving three girls with completely different looks to
vie for the title. Last year’s British BNBF Figure winner, Jo Fairbairn,
was invited onto the judging panel to help out for this one.
As usual, the contrasting figures before them gave the judges a headache.
1st: Lynn Thornton –
Tall and elegant, with long, slim legs, tiny waist and good back definition,
Lynn was the epitome of glamour, with just the right amount of “bling”
to enhance her presence without detracting or distracting from it. She was
the tightest, most toned girl in the class, very lean, yet shapely, and
her presentation and conduct throughout the day earned her the ladies’
Best Presentation award. I’d like to see Lynn add just a little more
muscle, especially on her legs, and she certainly shouldn’t get any
leaner, but on this showing, she is a good prospect for the Britain.
2nd: Julie Hind – Julie was a much stockier
girl, with more muscle mass than Lynn (though not too much for the class).
Her shape is good, with no bodypart really dominating or lagging. Her back
was nicely detailed, as were her abs, but she was a little soft, particularly
when compared with Lynn. Julie shouldn’t be afraid to glam it up a
little more for the finals, whilst still remembering that less can be more.
3rd: Frances Walton – Frances looked
very promising from the front, where she was tight with a good level of
muscularity for the class. Her execution of the quarter turns and compulsories
was exemplary, but when she turned to the rear, she was, unfortunately,
very soft in the hips and glutes, which need to be tightened for the finals.
HEAVYWEIGHTS - sponsored by Gasp Clothing
Only two in number, this class still managed to cause difficulties
for the judges. When two competitors are similar in shape, structure and
level of development, it can be as problematic as when no two physiques
are the same, and so it was today, with Jon Clark and Ian Munro. Jon was
ever-so-slightly ahead in the aesthetics department, whilst Ian had a slight
edge for muscularity, and was the more conditioned of the two. In an extremely
close contest, the decision went as follows:
1st: Jon Clark – after a break from all
the dieting that constant competing entails, Jon came back with his legs
much improved and more in line with his upper body. His upper body has always
had that extra something, due in no small part to his full, wide shoulders,
muscular arms and pecs and tiny waist. When Jon performs lat spreads, he
seems to fly. His posing as always was up there amongst the best in the
show. Jon did look better from the front; he looked ever-so-slightly soft
in the back by comparison, and he still needs more size on those lags, particularly
the inner thigh aspect and the hamstrings, but the improvements he had made
were enough to clinch the heavyweight title.
2nd: Ian Munro – Ian was similar to Jon
in many ways. His level of condition was such that he was detailed in every
muscle group, and, like Jon, his shaped was flared and aesthetic. Although
his legs were better than Jon’s, his upper body did not carry quite
the same level of shape and density, and in the end, it was a very close
call between the two, for many judges, coming down to the routine to be
able to split them.
OVERALL Mr. – sponsored by Extreme Nutrition
The culmination of the show saw Andrew
Chappell, Davy Reid, Tissot
Regis, Mike Battersby, Kerry
Napier and Jon Clark take their places
for what proved to be an epic battle, with many of the judges wishing they
could either spilt the prize or opt out of coming down in favour of any
one athlete.
With due respect to Andrew, Davy and Tissot, the real battle was between
the three weight-class winners.
The main problem was that no-one had everything; whilst they were all great
champions in their own right, none had the complete package that would have
made them a stand-out winner. Mike was thickly-developed
and in great condition, but he seemed to forget to pose his legs; Kerry
was unbeatable for density and leg development, but he seemed tired, and
didn’t execute his compulsories to show himself off to full advantage,
and he couldn’t compete with Jon for lat width. Jon
had his stupendous “wings” and aesthetic lines, yet was still
a little light in the legs, but, and herein lay the difference: Jon was
visibly fighting for this title.
The others might have wanted it, but Jon positively coveted it, and when
the others were visibly flagging, he was still fighting; his poses were
still bang-on after the umpteenth comparison, and in the end, it paid off,
as the delighted heavyweight took the over-all crown.
OVERVIEW
Once again, the BNBF team pulled out all the stops to produce a superb spectacle. Chairperson Vicky McCann was quick to pay tribute to the main show sponsor, Extreme Nutrition, to the class sponsors, to the backstage and behind-the-scenes teams who worked tirelessly all day to ensure the show ran smoothly and competitors’ needs were met, and last but not least, to the audience, who were fantastic in their support throughout the day.
Show report: Cheryl Myers
Photography: Calum McKenzie